beehiiv vs Substack
as AI assistants see them, week of 2026-10-26
beehiiv comes out ahead of Substack in how AI assistants talk about newsletter tools. beehiiv scores 28 overall (21 on ChatGPT, 41 on Claude) and gets named in 24 of 50 answers, versus Substack's 18 overall (14 on ChatGPT, 27 on Claude) and 16 of 50 answers. Head-to-head, beehiiv is named more often in 7 questions, Substack in none, with the other 18 tied. Both show up fully for questions like "best for a solo creator," "sponsors and ads," "selling a paid newsletter," and "alternatives to Kit." Neither is ever mentioned for CRM integration, ecommerce, or drip-email automation questions.
Head to head
| metric | beehiiv | Substack |
|---|---|---|
| score | 28 | 18 |
| questions won | 18 | 11 |
By assistant
beehiiv
| assistant | score | named in, this week | usual spot, this week |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 21 | 25% of answers | #1.8 |
| Claude | 41 | 65% of answers | #4.8 |
| Gemini | not sampled this week | ||
| Perplexity | not sampled this week |
Substack
| assistant | score | named in, this week | usual spot, this week |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 14 | 20% of answers | #3.8 |
| Claude | 27 | 45% of answers | #4.4 |
| Gemini | not sampled this week | ||
| Perplexity | not sampled this week |
Where they differ
Only beehiiv gets named for
- What's the best email platform that doesn't charge for duplicate subscribers?
- What's the best alternative to Mailchimp?
- Which email tool has the best deliverability?
- What's the best email marketing tool for a small business?
- What are the best alternatives to Mailchimp?
- What are the best alternatives to Brevo?
- What are the best alternatives to Klaviyo?
Only Substack gets named for
nothing exclusive
More comparisons
- beehiiv vs Klaviyo
- beehiiv vs Mailchimp
- ActiveCampaign vs beehiiv
- beehiiv vs Brevo
- HubSpot vs Substack
- Ghost vs Substack
Not sold on either?
Scores count how often each assistant names a product, weighted by position. How the score works · Full Email marketing platforms leaderboard